ECOSYSTEM RESTORATION AT THE LANDSCAPE SCALE: THE NORTH DELTA AND SUISUN MARSH
The purpose of this workshop was to provide information and guidance for large-scale ecosystem restoration efforts in the North Delta and Suisun Marsh by soliciting input from a panel of outside experts familiar with large-scale river floodplain and estuarine restoration elsewhere within the United States. The workshop brought together local scientists involved with the planning, implementation, evaluation, and management of large-scale restoration efforts with external experts familiar with large-scale restoration and landscape ecology.
WORKSHOP PRODUCTS AND MATERIALS
Final Report - Ecosystem Restoration at the Landscape Scale: The North Delta and Suisun Marsh
For workshop presentations please see the detailed agenda listed below.
Purpose
The purpose of this two-day (Nov. 18-19, 2009) workshop was to provide information and guidance for large-scale ecosystem restoration planning efforts in the North Delta and Suisun Marsh by soliciting input from a panel of outside experts familiar with large-scale river floodplain and estuarine restoration elsewhere within the United States. The workshop brought together local scientists involved with the planning, implementation, evaluation, and management of large-scale restoration efforts with external experts familiar with large-scale restoration and landscape ecology. There were four primary objectives for the workshop:
- discuss expectations for outcomes from large-scale restoration projects designed to provide habitats and conditions that assist putting listed aquatic species on pathways to recovery,
- provide a shared understanding of the knowledge base and restoration principles for large-scale restoration projects locally and nationally,
- identify and prioritize key questions and uncertainties that underpin large-scale restoration projects, and
- consider strategies for addressing these questions and uncertainties through implementing critical research combined with development of a robust evaluation program for local large-scale restoration projects.
Workshop Products
The panel of experts will produce an advisory report that will highlight principles for large-scale restoration, key questions and uncertainties to be considered going forward, approaches for addressing those uncertainties, and guidance on an effective monitoring and evaluation program for large-scale restoration projects. The presentations from the workshop will be posted on the CALFED Science Program website along with the agenda and a brief summary of the information conveyed and discussed throughout the workshop.
Expert Panel Members
- John Teal - Delaware Bay Salt Marsh Restoration - Panel Chair
- Jim Cloern US Geological Survey San Francisco Bay Long-term Research
- Nick Aumen - Everglades National Park
- John Wiens - Chief Scientist PRBO Conservation Science
- Karen Rodriguez - US EPA Great Lakes Restoration Initiative
Background Materials
- Brown, L. (2003) "Will Tidal Wetland Restoration Enhance Populations of Native Fishes?"
- The Bay-Delta Conservation Plan Chapter 3 Conservation Strategy (Suggest focusing on Biological Goals and Objectives Ch.3.3, pp. 3-17 to 3-44; other sections are good secondary background material):
- The Bay-Delta Conservation Plan-DRERIP Summary.
- Delta Vision Ecosystem Context Memo on 12 key ecological principles to guide Delta Vision (Mike Healey):
- Design Principles for a Sustainable Ecosystem in the Bay-Delta (Mike Healey):
Other Reference Materials
- Bay-Delta Conservation Plan working draft (Suggest Ch 2 Existing Conditions):
- The Final Delta Vision Strategic Plan (recent legislation incorporates key components of the plan):
- The State of Bay Delta Science from the CALFED Science Program
- The Public Policy Institute of California report on Comparing Futures for the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta:
Meeting Notice (pdf)
Detailed Agenda (pdf)
AGENDA DAY 1
- 9:00 AM Introduction to the Workshop Cliff Dahm and Organizers
- 9:15 AM Historical Ecology of the California Delta: Emerging Concepts of a Dynamic and Complex System - Robin Grossinger and Alison Whipple
- 9:45 AM Hydrodynamics and Transport Processes on the Pre-Settlement Landscape: Geomorphic Control of Functional Complexity and Implications for Restoration Chris Enright
- 10:15 AM Discussion
- 10:30 AM Break
- 10:45 AM Hydrodynamics of the Delta: Implications for Successful Restoration Jon Burau
- 11:15 AM Terrestrial Landscapes and Aquatic Ecosystems: Where are the Restoration Targets? John Wiens
- 11:45 AM Discussion
- 12:00 PM Lunch Break (Lunch on Your Own)
- 1:00 PM Environmental Flow Analyses for the Sacramento River Bill Fleenor
- 1:30 PM Hydrologic Regime: A Tool for Floodplain Restoration Betty Andrews
- 2:00 PM BREACH III: Evaluating and Predicting Restoration Thresholds in Evolving Freshwater Tidal Marshes Steve Crooks
- 2:30 PM Discussion
- 2:45 PM Break
- 3:00 PM The Great Lakes Restoration Initiative Karen Rodriguez
- 3:30 PM The National River Restoration Science Synthesis and the Kissimmee River Restoration Project Cliff Dahm
- 4:00 PM Californias Yolo Bypass: Opportunities for Restoration Ted Sommer
- 4:30 PM Discussion
- 4:45 PM Overall Discussion of Day 1 Presentations and Information
Agenda Day 2
- 9:00 AM Overview of Day 1 and Introduction to Day 2 Cliff Dahm
- 9:15 AM South Florida Ecosystem Restoration Efforts Nick Aumen
- 9:45 AM Restoration Principles We Established in New Jersey (and followed for the most part) John Teal
- 10:15 AM Discussion
- 10:30 AM Break
- 10:45 AM Fish, Regime Shifts, and the Future of Suisun Marsh Peter Moyle
- 11:15 AM Matching Our Actions with Our Goals: Bridging Restoration Design Concepts, Desired Ecosystem Functions, and Our Policy Frameworks Stuart Siegel
- 11:45 AM Large-scale and Long-term Monitoring and Scientific Investigations in the San Francisco Bay Jim Cloern
- 12:15 PM Discussion
- 12:30 PM Lunch Break (Lunch on Your Own)
- 1:30 PM Facilitated Discussion/Presentations with Workshop Attendees
- Note that external panel members will meet separately to discuss workshop report and prepare initial feedback
- 3:00 PM Break
- 3:15 PM Panel Feedback and Workshop Discussion with Panel
- 4:00 PM Public Comment
- 4:30 PM Adjourn